
The former St Joseph's care home at Cotham Hill. Developer Harringay wants to convert it into studio flats and cluster flats for 126 students.
Developer appeals after vote
to reject St Joseph’s plans. What happens now?
By Andrew Waller, 17 November 2026
Harringay Real Estate has filed an appeal against Bristol City Council’s rejection of its plans to convert the former St Joseph’s care home in Cotham Hill into accommodation for 126 students. This means the fate of the proposal now rests with a government planning inspector.
The appeal, which was expected, was submitted on 2 November and is now listed on the council and planning inspectorate websites. The appeal number is 6018753. (As a cross-check, the planning application reference is 26/11841/F.)
The appeal format is currently listed as “Written Part 1”, which means a planning inspector will look at documents only: the applicant’s submissions, the council officers’ reports, and comments previously submitted by the public. Third parties such as resident groups or individuals are not allowed to contribute further comments to Part 1 appeals.
However, the choice of format is not necessarily set in stone, and the inspectorate has discretion to change it to a Part 2 procedure, which would permit third-party submissions, or to a physical hearing. One of the criteria for the latter is where an application has attracted significant public attention.
The page to watch is https://appeal-planning-decision.service.gov.uk/comment-planning-appeal/appeals/6018753.
A March date with destiny?
No timetable is currently given for when the appeal might be determined. AI-assisted research indicates the wait for written-representation appeals is typically 18-20 weeks, which suggests March next year.
If so, it’s possible planning policies may have changed—to the benefit of objectors—by the time the inspector gets to work.
Throughout discussions of the St Joseph’s proposals, city planners said they could give only “limited weight” to provisions in Bristol’s revised Local Plan that might strengthen the case for refusal. The revised Plan is not yet in force because it’s still going through a lengthy process of examination by government inspectors. However, that is expected to conclude soon, allowing the city council to formally adopt the new version.
Crucially, the new Plan contains clearer policies on where and how much PBSA accommodation can be built—and the new provisions do not favour the St Joseph’s proposals. If the revised Plan has been adopted by the time the appeal is considered, the inspector will be obliged to refer to the new policies in judging the case. That might not, on its own, be enough to overturn the appeal but it would add to the arguments against it.
Comment: There are several other arguments that could also help the objectors’ case, but they may go unsaid unless the appeal is opened up to third-party representations.
As things stand, most of the council documents the inspector will see are officer reports recommending support for the development; the counter arguments from elected members in the two planning committee meetings were mostly verbal, not written. No doubt the developer will use the officers’ reports to support its own case.
That would be a perverse result, given that some of the objectors (including me) think the officers misapplied Bristol’s existing policies and thereby came to the wrong conclusions. Unless the appeal is opened up to third-party comment (and at the moment it's unclear how this could be done), the inspector will not receive evidence of those errors.
Related links:
October Meeting
September Meeting
My Objections
Free Newsletter
Want to stay up to date? It's easy—just take a few seconds to sign up to my email list. I send out a periodic e-bulletin summarising recent news. I may also send brief alerts if there's an important development. (See list lower down this page.) There are 390+ subscribers as of May 2026. Join them—and encourage me to keep going!
Operation Beech

Text police on 07773 816248 for help with student-related noise. Beech runs 8pm to 2am on Wed, Fri and Sat nights ONLY. More details >>>
Bulletins
St Joseph's Update (Oct 2026)
St Joseph's Update (Sep 2026)
St Joseph's Update (Jun 2026)
St Joseph's Update (May 2026)
Vote Now! (Mar 2026)
Testing Times at UoB (Sep 2024)
The data that shows 14% HMO concentration
6 October 2026
56
views
My analysis uses Bristol city council’s Pinpoint map (https://maps.bristol.gov.uk/pinpoint/): The light blue zone is the so-called Lower Super Output Area that most closely fits Cotham Hill (LSOA references E01014558 or 022B). HMOs are depicted by house icons (Mandatory in green, Additional in blue). PBSA is in olive green; St Joseph’s is in red because it’s at the application stage. Questions: Do the HMOs in the LSOA represent a “harmful concentration”, and if so would adding 126 PBSA beds...
My Public Forum Statement
11 September 2026
25
views
Statement submitted to Planning Committee B (meeting 2 September 2026) with respect to recommendation to approve change of use of St Joseph’s care home to student accommodation (application 26/11841/F). (I will not be able to attend the meeting, so this statement is submitted in writing only.) Submitted text follows: ---------------------- Chair, I endorse, in full, the objection submitted by Councillor Guy Poultney (Cotham), setting out very clearly why this application should be...
Planning Committee transcript, 2 Sep 2026
11 September 2026
35
views
Edited Transcript of YouTube video of Bristol City Council Planning Committee B on 2 September 2026: Planning application 26/11841/F for change of use of former St Joseph’s care home at Cotham Hill, Bristol, to student accommodation. Notes: 1. This is the YouTube transcript, edited by Andrew Waller, The Noise Pages (www.thenoisepages.com). I have removed unnecessary timestamps and “ums”, “ers” and other verbal tics, including duplicated words and phrases, and used ellipses (...) for...
My supplementary response
21 August 2026
24
views
This is the full text of the supplementary comments I submitted to the planning website on 18 August 2026 following a council invitation to participate in a second round of consultation. (I assume everyone who objected in the first round received this invitation. For most people, the second round closed on 19 August 2026.) ----------------------- I OBJECT to application 26/11841/F: Thank you for your letter of 5 August 2026 notifying revisions to this application and providing a further...